Open Tue–Sun · 11–5The Holiday Collection has arrived — shop online or visit us in Old BonitaSister shop: Old Bonita Surf Shop
The Brass Alligator — Home · Gift · Accessories
2

Our Story

Family, Community &
a Love of Unique Finds

A family-owned boutique in the heart of Old Bonita, filled with home décor, gifts and vintage treasures chosen one piece at a time.

The boutique floor with the painted logo wall and olive tree

The Family Behind the Shop

A Mother, Her Daughters & a Love of the Unexpected

The Brass Alligator was started by Brenda Atkinson in Bonita Springs, with the help of her daughters. It grew from something the family has always shared: a passion for finding unique, beautiful things — and for the people they get to share them with.

Rooted in family and community, the boutique was made to be a destination for home décor, gifts and vintage treasures where every customer feels welcome.

Portrait: Brenda Atkinson
Portrait: Brenda & her daughters
The boutique’s painted logo wall and olive treePastel cake stands and pillows on boutique shelves

Our Philosophy

“Welcoming, inspiring, and a little unexpected.”

That’s how we hope every visit feels — and it’s how we choose every piece on our shelves.

Collected, Not Mass-Produced

We look for pieces with character — the kind that feel like they’ve always belonged in your home.

Local Artists

Original paintings, miniatures, resin work and handmade pieces from Southwest Florida makers.

A Welcome Every Time

Family-run means you’ll be greeted like a neighbor, whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth.

Giving Back

We’re strong supporters of local animal rescue — community is the heart of what we do.

Handmade pieces and cards on the boutique’s round table

Local Artists & Curated Finds

Made Nearby. Found With Care.

We work with many local artists who bring one-of-a-kind pieces into the shop — miniature paintings, resin trays, jewelry and more. Alongside them you’ll find vintage treasures, each one chosen by hand.

Featured artist
Featured artist
Featured artist

Community & Animal Rescue

Giving Back Is Part of the Family Business

We’re strong supporters of local animal rescue efforts, and giving back to the community that welcomed us is central to who we are.

Rescue PartnersNames & logos to confirm
Adoption DaysIf hosted — to confirm
Donation DrivesSeasonal — to confirm
Community EventsCalendar via Shopify blog

Coming Summer 2027

Old Bonita Surf Shop

The family is growing the business with a new shop in Old Bonita. Sign up for the letter to hear first.

Get Updates